Call Us Today! 219-326-7575

Call Us Today! 555-5555
Write Us a Review

Trusted Insurance Services, Personalized Results

Personal Insurance

Since opening in the 1950s, Tillinghast Insurance Agency has helped families across La Porte County, Indiana find the insurance policies to fit their needs, lifestyle, and budget. As an independently owned and operated agency, we are able to provide our clients with competitive rates and customized services. Life is filled with a lot of twists and turns, so it is our goal to help you achieve peace of mind knowing you have the right insurance coverage for whatever challenges life throws at you.

Providing Your Family With the Comfort & Security You Deserve

Vehicle Insurance

An important part of staying safe on the road is making sure you have the appropriate vehicle insurance policy. This type of coverage provides protection from loses due to collision, theft, fire, and acts of nature. We underwrite policies which cover a full range of vehicle types. We will work with you to find the insurance plans which fit your needs and budget while providing you with the protection you deserve.

  • Car Insurance
  • Truck Insurance
  • SUV Insurance
  • Motorcycle Insurance
  • Watercraft Insurance
  • Boat Insurance

Looking for Commercial Auto Insurance Options?
Visit Our Commercial Insurance Page!

Homeowners Insurance

Your home is one of the most important investments in your life, so make sure it is protected. A home insurance policy provides protection and financial assistance against damages or theft to your home, natural disasters, as well as liability claims in the event someone is injured on your property. This type of policy not only protects your possessions but your family as well.

Personal Umbrella Insurance

For many clients, an umbrella policy provides an additional layer of security. This type of policy provides supplementary protection in the event damages exceed the coverage of your standard policies. Coverage includes:

  • Car accidents
  • Accidental injuries on your property
  • Accidents involving your boat, ATV, or another recreational vehicle
  • Golf course injuries
  • Defense fees and other legal costs
  • Personal injury coverage for claims of libel, slander, and more

Scheduled Personal Property

While your homeowners insurance provides comprehensive coverage, it may have set limitations on the amount the insurance company will pay for specific losses. Possessions which may have limited coverage include jewelry, fine art, gold coins, antiques, and more. A scheduled personal property plan provides coverage beyond that offered in a standard homeowners policy and allows you to extend coverage to your most prized possessions.

Renters Insurance

Whether you rent an apartment, condo, or house, it is important to have renters insurance to protect your belongings. In the event of a fire, water damage, or break-in, your landlord’s homeowners insurance may not cover any damages you incur. We offer affordable rental insurance policies to provide you with additional peace of mind and protection.

Life Insurance

Because people are living longer, life insurance premiums are more affordable. While it is hard to think about, a life insurance policy can provide your family with the security they need in the event you are suddenly gone. There are many life insurance options available to you and your loved ones, and we will work with you to keep your family and assets protected.

Have questions? Ready to schedule an appointment? Contact our experienced team today at 219-326-7575.


Tillinghast Insurance Agency
111 Pine Lake Ave
La Porte, IN 46350

Monday – Friday:
8:30 AM – 5:00 pm
By Appointment only.